Monday, November 16, 2020

Is Global Warming man made? nahhh.

Spudtater Musings

Do I believe in Global Warming? 

    Yes. Global warming is the Earth getting 1 degree Celsius hotter over 100 years of data collection. 

Man Made? 

    Most likely not. I'll have to say "no-absolutely not" if I am forced to chose at this time. 

(I do not advocate for pollution. I believe in clean air and water and being respectful stewards.)

Why disagree with the vast majority of climate scientists on this? 


1A. I fear scientific agreement because science never concludes. We ALWAYS learn more than we think we know. The smartest scientist keeps asking why like Sakichi Toyoda. The greatest minds upset convention: Bohr with the atom; Planck with quantum theory; da Vinci with ingenuity; Galileo with physics; Tesla with electricity; Einstein with space and time; Newton with calculus and gravity.

1B. There are plenty of scientific consensus proven wrong: Biology with Spontaneous generation proven wrong by Pasteur; Chemistry's classical elements proven wrong by Lavoisier; Aristotelian physics superseded by Newton (maybe again with relativistic and quantum physics); Astronomy's Newtonian gravity with general relativity; Geography's flat earth and hollow earth theories by observation; Geology's plate tectonics replaced many theories; Medicine's Miasma theory of "bad air" causing disease; and whole branches of debunked science like alchemy, astrology, eugenics, phrenology and numerology. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superseded_theories_in_science)

2. We are coming out of an Ice Age. There is no consensus on the amount of "normal warming". If no one knows the variable of normal warming how can they calculate the other variable of man made warming? Is 1 degree Celsius "normal"?

3. We can't 100% predict local weather. How can we 100% understand global weather? Between 1940 and 1970 the earth was cooling. So the leading 1/6th of climatologists in the 70's predicted a new mini ice age caused by human "aerosols" like smog put into the atmosphere. In the 80's we are back to global warming consensus but this time we left the human cause not the normal end of an Ice Age.

4. We always point to the Industrial Revolution and fossil fuels as our culprit to global warming. Oil/Natural Gas (Szechuan China), Tar (ship building) and asphalt (ancient Bagdad) were known in preindustrial times. Fact is: oil is not from dinosaurs. It's from decaying marine organisms from the Paleozoic Era (before dinosaurs) and Mesozoic Era (age of dinosaurs). There wasn't enough dinosaurs to make our oil. Your belief that oil is from dinosaurs is a successful marketing campaign by Sinclair in the 1930's. It's from ancient Plankton. Taking a big picture, petroleum (like everything else) is a solar energy. If given enough time/ages will this carbon also become a future renewable energy like the Plankton? I get we are taking carbon from an ancient age and putting it in our atmosphere. The question of this "overwhelming" our planet is the issue. How about the opposite? Is the shade from our solar panels robbing the earth of it's energy? Is this "underwhelming" the planet? (https://www.powells.com/post/original-essays/does-oil-come-from-dinosaurs)

5. Sunspots -- first observed by the ancient Chinese and Korean astronomers. We get all our energy from the Sun. Light, radiation, rotational pull etc. Our sun is not stable, it is aging too. The sun reverses polarity every 11 years. We can use carbon dating to determine these cycles going back 11,400 years. Fossil records indicate the solar cycle has been the roughly the same length for 700 million years and activity in the 1940's were exceptional. The previous exceptional period of magnitude was 9,000 years ago. If we were to replicate a universe by putting a heater in a huge room, vary the heater while changing the surface of a rotating object - which causes more change/effect of heat? The change in the surface or the heater? In this experiment we must draw out the object's new surface from it's interior (like oil). Is the object really changing if no new material is added to it? Isn't it way more significant that our Earth's only heater varies? Does it make since to compare between the heater and the object being heated which causes more heat? Scientifically. How can this variance be ruled out? Especially given any computational models must have human bias in it's setup. 

6. Natural disasters have been happening since we started recording history. I won't list Earthquakes but the first recorded earthquake description is almost 3,200 years ago (1177BC) in China. In 1228 Netherlands, the sea flooded killing 100,000 people. In the 1300's Arizona and New Mexico's rivers disappeared causing death and destruction. In 1316 England, heavy rains ruined crops killing 1/10th of the population. Hurricanes in 1776 and 1780 killed over 26,000 people in the West Indies and the Americas. All this before the Industrial Revolution. The 1888 blizzard killed 400 people on the east coast (USA) and a flood a year later in Johnstown PA killed 2,200 people. Locally, in 1908, the Ohio River dried up to a creek. When any of these things happen today like California drying up - we blame mankind, not the Earth.

When Dr. Roger Pielke, an extreme weather expert at the University of Colorado, was asked if hurricanes, tornados, or droughts were increasing he stated that according to the EPA and IPCC the answer was, "NO".

There is no difference between now and before the industrial revolution except our ability to record better history. And blame ourselves, then feel guilty for being ourselves. Given the big picture, I don't see how we insignificant minuscule organisms can destroy anything other than ourselves. Like it has before, the day after the nuke, our universe (and maybe the Earth) will continue without us.

No comments: