Spudtater Musings
I was looking through my old blog here and found that a video I had a link to was removed from the webs. In an effort to find it again, I came across this blog which I liked.
https://thinkprogress.org/neil-degrasse-tyson-shows-science-and-religion-can-co-exist-in-cosmos-3e4484fdd41b#.48wr41rd7
I like to hear the Mr. Tyson is an agnostic. It's not a denial of God but rather a denial of our understanding of God. There is a big difference. For scientific agnostics, it's a matter of defining God. Ironically, it's the same position of Mr. Giordano Bruno, the ex-domincan monk who left the Catholic Church and was later burned at the stake for his denial that Christ is God.
Mr. Tyson goes on to say in a program on the cosmos that Mr. Bruno was not a scientist and that Mr. Bruno's discovery (that the universe is filled with stars and planets like our solar system) was a lucky guess. Mr. Tyson, like Mr. Bruno, both have the observed cosmos, mathematics, logic, denial of Christ as God, and visiting university professorships in common. What I find most ironic, is that Mr. Tyson and Mr. Bruno are the same despite the difference in time. If these things doesn't make Mr. Bruno a scientist, then there isn't much left for Mr. Tyson either.
Yet, in an "I Further" National Geographic TV commercial Mr. Tyson states "I think every child is a scientist. The moment a child crawls, their exploring their environment. It is no different than what a scientist does. All a scientist is, is a kid who never grew up."
If Mr. Bruno is not a scientist (even as a child) then it begs the question as to what qualifications does it take to become one? How is it that Mr. Bruno and Mr. Tyson have the same qualifications, yet one denies the other the same privilege? Well I'm forced to agree with Mr. Tyson, he's not a scientist, he's just opinionated. If Mr. Tyson would spend his time postulating on the universe and have an original thought outside of the denial of others, he might be remembered in history like Mr. Bruno.
Mr. Bruno postulated a scientific theory in 1584 that hasn't been disproved. I don't read Mr. Tyson, but I'm not aware of a scientific theory he has proposed, or even proved. In my book, that makes Mr. Bruno an outstanding scientist, and Mr. Tyson his student who will be barely remembered by History. Maybe Mr. Tyson is just a talking head.
Look, I don't dislike the guy. I admire that he is trying to advance our knowledge. I just wish he was wiser, not smarter. Wisdom is needed to see his ideas through to their conclusions, to see where he contradicts himself. Maybe he doesn't see the clockwork of the universe requiring a clock maker. Maybe he doesn't see that life holds atoms together in a mystery while the dead universe scatters atoms as a rule. Maybe he didn't write the Cosmos show, but he should have seen that by castigating Mr. Bruno, he was castigating himself.
This Week in Tech 1110: High-End Electronic Drumkits
-
A nationwide FAA ground halt and a global Microsoft 365 outage reveal just
how fragile our high-tech infrastructure has become, with finger-pointing,
con...
7 hours ago
No comments:
Post a Comment