Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Stupid Design by Neil deGrasse Tyson



[I originally had a video of Neil Degrasse Tyson giving a lecture - but it has since been removed.]


My Stupid Design Response (yeah, I called my response stupid...)

This is in response to Neil Degrasse Tyson in relation to his "stupid design" topic about how the universe is created with stupid design.

Everything Mr. Tyson states is spot on. I do not disagree with anything he has stated about the design of the universe. He is correct in thinking that the universe is designed in such a manner that life seems incredible - downright unbelievable when looked at from the viewpoint that almost everything about our universe seems contrary against life actually existing. Yet it does exist. Tyson does not argue life doesn't exist. He does not stand before us and argue that he doesn't exist. He simply states life exist despite the universe itself which is very very true.

Mr. Tyson further doesn't argue whether his own view is stupid or intelligent. If the universe has a stupid design then by argument all our reason upon it has to be by definition stupid. How can we as intelligent beings argue against intelligence in the universe we live in? The answer must be that Mr. Tyson is stupid because the universe as he understands it has stupid design by having him in it. This is the argument that G.K. Chesterton reasoned as the "suicide of thought". That some thoughts by themselves argue for their own suicide. These arguments sound plausible on the surface but lack any basis of logical reason.

Take any modern machine a human person has invented, especially if that modern machine is something we fix on a regular basis -- because a human invented it. We might have imagined a wheel, a hammer, a clock, a car, a computer, a copier... it could be anything. Obviously at some point in our repair we stated "what was that inventor thinking?" "Didn't they know it would eventually break because..." We can doubt the sustainability of the inventor's invention but what we cannot do is state that the invention was without intelligent design. The inventor didn't invent from being stupid with his design. He knew what he wanted to invent from the beginning or it wouldn't exist today for us to repair. The inventor had a purpose, an intelligent design that assembled it.

Intelligent or stupid design seems to miss the point altogether. That life exists is what matters. That an intelligent being can argue on the universe having a stupid or intelligent design seems to be the exact point Mr. Tyson fails to grasp. Obviously Mr. Tyson is intelligent; very intelligent.  So too must be the design of the universe that allows for Mr. Tyson to have intelligence. Obviously Mr. Tyson doesn't deny carbon as an element while he is clearly made up of carbon based life. He understands intelligence because he recognizes it around him within the universe. His intelligence was not self created. Mr. Tyson fails to see where he is standing or rather poses his argument. His perspective is outside of the universe as the only intelligence (or life form made by intelligence) while pointing out the rest of the universe was designed by a stupid maker. He stands within this universe looking outside of it while also participating within it. Mr. Tyson is alive. He is part of this invention called life.

Amazingly, this invention allows us to see ourselves within this invention and also imagine ourselves apart from it. This is precisely why we reason that we are most like our creator. We can understand.  Other life forms like a crocodile that eats one chicken a month or the dolphin, the mammal that breaths and eats from different holes, cannot comprehend life beyond their own noses (if they even have that).  We have barely scratched the surface in our own understanding or how we understand anything.  Mr. Tyson is a renowned astrophysicist known for his nonchalant agnostic views regarding a non-benevolent stupid creator, so I really don’t expect Mr. Tyson to give us a complete historical viewpoint of Logic itself, or the history of Logic and its application. After all, “inductive reasoning” itself wasn’t considered until Francis Bacon postulated it in the 1600’s. Mr. Tyson may use this inductive reasoning method for science and still misapply that same logical method for his understanding about the universe, philosophy, or life. We barely understand how we understand and even apply Logic, much less infer or make judgments beyond life other than life exists. Life does exist everyone agrees. I have a tee shirt that states “God is Life. The rest is just details.” How appropriate for Mr. Tyson and for us. Life itself is what matters, not what is contrary to life itself like the universe. Arguing the intelligence of something is really not relevant when what matters is the something. 

That machine/invention only works the way it does because it is in a state of working or not working. It has a tolerance for its working state as well as for it non-functional state. What I mean is that every time the invention is used, the wear and tear and age affect how it operates. Time is of the essence and so it has been since the “big bang” if you like that understanding. It doesn’t work while it is being created. Once used, it no longer acts new; there are tolerances for its condition as it remains working. Even more tolerances as for when it doesn't work because there are thousands or trillions of ways to break an invention, like when the guys “beat down” the printer in office space. In fact, we know from fixing these items that they usually only work they way they are intelligently designed and not by any other design stupid or otherwise. Even if it says "PC LOAD LETTER", someone invented it.

Mr. Tyson is simply pointing out the many tolerances of how life works and the vast tolerances of how life doesn't work. What we know without doubt is how life is supposed to work because it is universally understood principle. If life works at its best, then with even a sliver of the intelligence Mr. Tyson displays, we can reason there is an inventor that made it with an intelligent design for a purpose. Everything ever invented has a purpose. Intelligence alone is enough of a reason for life to make it so.

Mr. Tyson brings this subject up to point out that he thinks so-called "intelligent design" obscures or slows down scientific understanding. I yet again disagree and would like to point out that so far, the majority of our understanding of science is from believers in an intelligent designer. It was their faith in this designer to want to understand more about the design and therefore more about the designer. They are way to numerous to mention but those scientific saints gave you their gift of the science you love today. It is a history of faith and of human understanding itself. Hugh of Saint Victor (c.1096–1141) has a resounding message, "Learn everything, later you will see that nothing is superfluous."  

Life is an assembly. Mr. Tyson points out very well that the universe tears everything apart; however life assembles elements for a purpose. Even now while you read this your life form is assembling atoms to fathom itself. Not once in history has an invention assembled itself, but rather it was an intelligence that did the assembly. That item you fix on a regular basis didn't assemble itself. Life is (and was) assembled to create you.  Mr. Tyson doesn’t deny a creator God or an intelligent design by pointing out it's flaws but rather almost proves what an amazing invention life "is". He simply is arguing his creator’s stupidity which is profoundly irrelevant.

I guess what I'm trying to say it that even a stupid design has some degree of intelligence. Should we really be arguing over how much intelligence, and not focus on the inventor instead?

Scott Anthony Hibbs
11/19/13


Spudtater Musings

No comments: